Ice Cream Man
So you know how I’ve sometimes referred to movies as “not very good”? In almost all cases, you can translate that as “not very good, but it is a professionally made movie that knows how to be a movie competently, and just forgets to have any reason to exist.” Which I mention because this is the other kind of “not very good” movie — the one made by people who don’t really know how to make movies, and who end up just throwing a bunch of stuff onto the screen.
Objectively, that means it’s terrible. And it really is terrible! Clint Howard is creepy, sure, but that’s just because he’s Clint Howard; his character doesn’t really make sense, and is written inconsistently. Everyone else’s characters are even worse, and yet somehow, this is a movie whose characters are its strength, relative to its plotting and visuals. It’s just a literally amateur effort, made by people who didn’t know how to do what they were trying to do.
And yet… precisely because it’s such a failure, it’s arguably more interesting than a bland pile of smooth nothing like Hard Target. Nobody will like this movie, nobody will think it’s good. But to paraphrase Mark Twain and/or Winston Churchill, every mediocre movie is alike; each terrible movie is terrible in its own way. Five years from now, I will literally have to look back at my records to see if I watched Hard Target, but I am never going to forget that I watched this movie about a weird and murderous ice cream man, and Jan-Michael Vincent sleepwalking through a role as a cop.